Insurance Agency in Bloomington: Your Trusted Partner

We observe students and families walk by our windows daily, reminding us daily why we love assisting our neighbors in protecting what’s most important. If you’re looking for a Bloomington insurance agency that’s like family, you’ll find us welcoming with open arms and plain-talk advice.

Our roots go deep in this college town, where the intellectual rigor and small-town hospitality make for a special community we’re honored to serve. From keeping first-time homeowners safe in their Eastside bungalows to safeguarding expanding families in their Southside houses, we’ve earned our neighbors’ trust over decades. As your hometown insurance agency in Bloomington, we understand your language – whether you’re a seasoned prof trying to safeguard your retirement or a grad student taking your initial steps toward financial stability.

Why Select Shine Insurance in Bloomington

As your neighbors, we view the world from your perspective. Our agents live right in Bloomington – we shop the same shops, dine at the same restaurants, and experience the same local issues. This local expertise is what enables us to craft insurance solutions that will actually work their way into your life.

We’re not afraid to talk straight about insurance. No jargon or hard-to-pronounce terms – just straight talk about safeguarding your tomorrow. When you come through our doors, you’ll find real people who actually listen and take the time to explain things in a way that makes sense. Our clients tell us time and time again it’s as much like talking with a friend as visiting an insurance agent.

Plus, being downtown puts us where you need us. The majority of our clients drop by during their lunch break or when conducting business along Kirkwood Avenue. We’ve brought insurance into your corner by making it convenient and accessible for busy Bloomington residents.

Our Prime Location in Downtown Bloomington

Being located in the middle of downtown at 101 W Kirkwood Ave gives our insurance agency something special. We’re only a short walk from the Monroe County Courthouse Square, making it easy to recall where we’re located.

Following are 5 reasons why our location is beneficial to our customers:

1. Coffee Before Coverage – We are two doors from Hopscotch Coffee. Many clients drop by for their beverage of choice before coming in to see us.
2. Lunch and Learn – Being neighbors with Lennie’s and BuffaLouie’s gives you the option to turn your insurance meeting into a lunch meeting.
3. Easy Parking – The 4th Street Parking Garage is just around the corner.
4. Study Break Solutions – IU students who visit from the library tend to find us in between study sessions.
5. Shopping Convenience – Because there are local shops nearby, you can do insurance while running errands.

Getting to Shine Insurance from Bloomington

If you’re coming from downtown Bloomington, it’s easy to get to us. Start on E 3rd Street and head west towards downtown. Turn right onto N College Avenue, then take your first left onto E Kirkwood Avenue. You’ll pass the Sample Gates on your right. Continue straight for approximately two blocks – you will notice the Monroe County Courthouse on your left. We are 101 W Kirkwood Ave, Suite 134, mid-block. Our sign will be between the restaurant and coffee shop.

From the east side of Bloomington, head west on E 3rd Street toward downtown. Turn right onto S College Ave, and turn left almost immediately onto Kirkwood Avenue. We’re on your right after you pass over the courthouse square.

From the west side, head east on W 3rd Street to N College Ave. Turn left, then right on Kirkwood. We’re on the left side of the road, just past the square.

Riding the Bus to Shine Insurance

The Bloomington Transit has made visiting our office easy. Route 1 and Route 3 both stop directly at the downtown square, putting you within less than a minute’s walk from our front door.

If you are coming from the College Mall side of Route 1, you may catch the bus at any of the stops along E 3rd Street. The bus operates every 30 minutes on weekdays. Take the bus to the downtown square stop – you won’t be able to miss the courthouse. Walk west on Kirkwood for a half a block, and our office is located at 101 W Kirkwood.

Route 3 on Bloomington’s south side also lets you off at the square. Route 3 runs through the Broadview and Henderson Court areas, with buses running by hourly. After getting off at the square, we’re a short walk.

Both routes operate Monday to Saturday, with limited service on weekends. Take a look at the Bloomington Transit website for current schedules – they do update times from time to time around IU breaks.

Places to Eat and Stay Close to Our Office

Hungry for a bite or needing a night’s accommodation? We have great options just around our office:

Contact Shine Insurance Today

Life is busy – we understand. So we’ve tried to make it as simple as possible to reach us. Stop by our downtown office at 101 W Kirkwood Ave Suite 134, Bloomington, IN 47404. We’re always glad to talk insurance, ask questions, or just hi.

Call 812-679-8779. Whether you’re trying to select the perfect coverage or need to change your policy, we’re here for you. Our staff enjoys meeting our Bloomington neighbors and making insurance more of a conversation and less of a task.

And as a reminder, being downtown, it’s easy to stop by when you’re already out. Several of our customers stop by on their lunch break, or after visiting the coffee shop next door. No appointment is necessary – just stop by and we’ll discuss your options for insuring what’s most important to you.